Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy
Consider it a tribute to Dannel Malloy’s version of American Capitalism…
You’ll find this cute little “feel good” story in this week’s Hartford Business Journal.
“Brewing Opportunity – Startup’s K-cup vending machine offers employers money-saving option” is an article about how an employee at the Connecticut Center for Advanced Technology in East Hartford got an idea for a new product when he was instructed to go out and purchase a Keurig coffee brewer for the company lunch room.
By 2015, the employee is hoping his company makes in excess of $1 million.
The employee got the idea that there was room in the marketplace for a machine that sold individual 10 gram, single-serve K-cups. The K-cup vending machine is undoubtedly helpful for those employers who refuse to provide their employees with free single-serve K-cups.
The article goes on to explain that this employee took his idea and went to a “Chinese manufacturer… because the firm produced a similarly designed product” and “China is also considered a lower cost production center.”
And today he is making money selling these machines.
And then comes the kicker…
To help the company get started, Governor Malloy’s Department of Economic Development gave the start-up company, KK Manufacturing, a $35,000 grant.
Meaning that Governor Malloy borrowed $35,000 on the taxpayer’s credit card and then gave it to the private company. Connecticut’s taxpayers will then have to pay back the $35,000, over the next twenty years, along with the additional hundreds of millions that Malloy has borrowed to give to other private companies.
In this case, the company’s owner said the grant was a huge help.
As the Hartford Business Journal article explains, “KK Manufacturing is now generating revenue. Striebel [the company’s owner] said he expects to be a ‘healthy six-figure company’ in 2014, and thinks there’s potential to breach the $1 million sales mark in 2015.
He’s going to hire his first sales and customer service employee in the next year — a pledge he made to get the state funding. He hopes there will be more to come.”
What a great commentary about “Modern American Capitalism.”
We’ve developed an economic system in which the government borrows money – that the taxpayers must pay back with interest – and gives it to private businesses so that they, in turn, can make money.
No disrespect intended for KK manufacturing, but can I have my share of my money back. I need it to pay my taxes.
You can read the article and see the new machine at: http://www.hartfordbusiness.com/article/20131028/PRINTEDITION/131029932
Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy
With the help of $11.5 million in taxpayer funds, Governor Malloy proudly announced that he was able to convince The Navigators Group, Inc., an extremely profitable “international specialty insurance holding company with insurance company operations, underwriting management companies and operations at Lloyd’s of London” to move from Rye, New York to Stamford Connecticut.
According to the Malloy administration, the state of Connecticut will provide the private insurance company with a 10-year, $8 million forgivable loan at no interest. The Navigators Group will also receive a $3.5 million grant to help offset the $25 million relocation cost.
The company employs 87 people at the Stamford location, with an additional 35 across the state. If the company creates 200 jobs within the next five years it will not have to pay back the $8 million, no interest loan.
If it fails to create the jobs, the no-interest loan will have to be paid back.
Since the State of Connecticut is borrowing the $11.5 million to give to the Navigators Group, the actual cost to Connecticut’s taxpayers over the next 20 years will be in the range of $15 million. The amount of state debt per capita already places Connecticut as the most debt ridden state in the in the nation. While the average state debt per capita across the country is about $1,400, Connecticut’s state debt per capita amount is over $5,800.
According to official filings, the Navigators Group has been doing very well. Last year, the company’s net income was $63.8 million, up from $25.6 million in 2011.
The company’s net income per share had its best showing since 2007.
And the company’s operating earnings were $37.6 million, up from $19.1 million in 2011. The jump in earnings came despite net losses of $20.4 million as a result of Superstorm Sandy.
According to the company’s financial filings, Stanley Galanski, the President and Chief Executive Officer of NAVIGATORS GROUP INC, made $2,714,948 in 2012. Of this total, $725,000 was received as a salary, $372,000 was received as a bonus, $1,574,396 was awarded as stock and $43,552 came from other types of compensation.
Navigators Group Inc.’s other corporate officers include:
Stephen R. Coward: $856,933 in total compensation.
Ciro M. DeFalco: $1,004,503 in total compensation.
H. Clay Bassett Jr.: $1,028,407 in total compensation.
Vincent C. Tizzio: 1,854,513 in total compensation.
And for those who think using taxpayer funds to subsidize extremely successful business isn’t all it is cracked up to be, in what appeared to be a related announcement, “Navigators Group, in partnership with Cos Cob-based Kids In Crisis, announced it will be the title sponsor of the Navigators Stamford KIC IT Triathlon. The June event consists of a 1.5-kilometer swim in Long Island Sound, a 40K bicycle ride and a 10K run through Stamford.”
Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Ethics, Malloy, Prosperity for Connecticut PAC Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Ethics, Malloy, Prosperity for Connecticut PAC
Thanks to Governor Malloy’s corporate welfare program, Connecticut’s taxpayers provided a Connecticut company with a $100,000 loan and another $26,320 grant to pay for their move from Bloomfield to Hartford.
Malloy said the grant would help Connecticut’s jobless problem by retaining 11 jobs.
In a press release as the time, Governor Malloy explained, “Hybrid Insurance Agency LLC is a full-service, underwriting management and wholesale insurance brokerage firm. This is a fast-growing insurance group, beginning operations in March of 2010 in Windsor, a year later opening a satellite office in Columbus, Ohio, and a service operation in Kathmandu, Nepal. They currently have 11 employees in their headquarters and approximately 650 retail agents and brokers. A $100,000 loan and a $26,320 matching grant will go toward the relocation of the headquarters to Hartford. The project will retain 11 employees.”
Now the owner of Hybrid Insurance Agency reportedly works from home, most of the employees are apparently no longer employed and the company has defaulted on the loan that it received from Malloy’s economic development operation.
Hybrid Insurance is also is under investigation for allegedly failing to pass along $670,000 in premiums to two of the City of Hartford’s insurance carriers.
According to a story written by Hartford Courant columnist and blogger, Kevin Rennie, the Hartford Internal Audit Commission has been asked to investigate Adam Cloud, Hartford’s City Treasurer, “for what they called a possible conflict of interest involving Hybrid, which is at 30 Lewis St. — a building owned by Cloud, his brother Christopher and their father, Sanford “Sandy” Cloud Jr.”
Rennie reports that “Paula Altieri, the city school system’s chief financial officer, stated in a memorandum that Cloud’s office “moved” an insurance policy from one broker to Hybrid around February 2012 “without the need to compete.”
Meanwhile, Hybrid Insurance made an appearance earlier this year in a Wait, What? post when it was noted that the lobbyists for Hybrid Insurance were among those that attended the Prosperity for Connecticut Political Action Committee fundraiser in Hartford.
Prosperity for Connecticut is the PAC affiliated with Governor Malloy and that raised over $235,000 thanks to 15 fundraisers held over an 18 month period. Governor Malloy apparently attended all 15 fundraisers, with three held in Washington D.C., three in New York City and the rest in Connecticut.
Lt. Governor Nancy Wyman joined Malloy at the Hartford event which was targeted to raise donations from Connecticut lobbyists.
Hybrid Insurance has worked with the lobby firm of Camilliere, Cloud and Kennedy for the past two years, paying the lobbyists a total of $26,900. Christopher Cloud, Adam Cloud’s twin brother, is one of the partners and the lobby firm’s offices are located in the same building that “houses” Hybrid Insurance and is owned by the Cloud brothers and their father.
Today Hartford City Treasurer Adam Cloud had a letter to the editor in the Hartford Courant clarifying his role in the whole affair. Adam Cloud wrote;
“I would like to clarify some points made in recent articles about the Hartford treasurer’s office and Hybrid Insurance Group [Oct. 11, news, “Officials Call For Audit Of Treasurer”; Oct. 10, Kevin Rennie column, courantopinion.com, “Who's Got Hartford's Missing $669,997?”].
There are two insurance policies being discussed. First, the smaller pension fund policy was recommended by an insurance agency that had solicited a reduced-cost proposal from Hybrid. The bid was approved by the office of the corporation counsel and the pension commission, not our office.
As for the insurance coverage for the city and the schools, the selection of the insurance was made by an independent committee that neither I nor anyone in my staff was a member of. My office did not approve any business relationship between the city and Hybrid.
It is the finance department, which does not report to the treasurer’s office, that processes payments to vendors. When our office was notified that the carrier had not been paid by Hybrid, and the city could be in danger of an insurance coverage lapse, I engaged the finance department. In consultation with former city Finance Director Julio Molleda, we transferred the funds.
This is not an uncommon occurrence in managing the finances of a large city. It was my intent to protect the city from any potential financial dangers with no insurance.
The fact that Hybrid has an office in a building in which my family and I have an ownership interest had no bearing on this decision. Upon becoming treasurer, I relinquished any management responsibilities of this building.
Finally, it is important to note that in accordance with state law, at no time was the city uninsured. The city does not have to recoup the payment or make any additional payments; this is the carrier’s responsibility.
I strongly support the state Department of Insurance investigation of Hybrid and the city’s internal audit department’s review.
Adam Cloud, Hartford City Treasurer.
And lest it falls through the cracks, the only person who raised concerns about Malloy’s gift to Hybrid Insurance in the first place was Bloomfield’s State Representative who asked why state funds were being used to persuade a company to move from his district into Hartford.
At the time Baram said, “The loan program should primarily focus on growing small businesses in the local community where they are located… ”I will be conveying my disappointment to the governor’s office, urging the Department of Economic and Community Development to award future loans and grants that will allow companies to remain local.”
BassPro, Bridgeport, Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy, Mayor Bill Finch BassPro, Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy, Mayor Bill Finch
“Bass Pro often fails to deliver on its promise to be an economic development anchor and major tourist destination. Its stores attract shoppers but often do not produce sought-after economic benefits associated with major tourist destinations.” (Public Accountability Initiative 2010)
“The stores are billed as job generators by both companies when they are fishing for development dollars. But the firms’ economic benefits are minimal and costs to taxpayers are great.” (Franklin Center for Government & Public Integrity 2012)
This coming Friday, Governor Malloy’s State Bond Commission will authorize $31,000,000 in bonds to subsidize the construction of a Bass Bro “retail facility” at Steel Point Harbor in the City of Bridgeport. When the full bill for the principal and interest is paid off this taxpayer gift will cost the citizens of Connecticut in excess of $45 million.
The Governor’s promise to give Bass Pro public funds dates back to July 2012 when he attended a Bridgeport press conference with Bass Pro’s owner, Johnny Morris, to proudly proclaim, “This is about jobs, and it’s great news for the City of Bridgeport…Bass Pro will be a draw for people from throughout the region, one that will help revive the local economy.”
At the time, Mayor Bill Finch chimed in, “Today’s announcement marks a historic moment for the City of Bridgeport and SteelPointe Harbor. Bass Pro Shops’ investment in Bridgeport will create hundreds of jobs, generate new tax revenues and bring economic growth to the City. They are a proven brand that will generate interest and attract customers from throughout the region. Bass Pro Shops is committed to Bridgeport and we are proud to have them as a major anchor tenant at Steelpointe Harbor.”
The total cost of the proposed store is estimated at $68.5 million, but the $31 million in state subsidies doesn’t even count the cost of improvements and tax abatements that the City of Bridgeport will be providing Bass Pro.
Over the years, Bass Pro, a privately held company with at least $2.6 billion in annual revenue, has relied heavily on taxpayer subsidies to pay for the construction of its stores by suggesting that they will create hundreds of jobs and become major tourist attractions.
Last year, the Franklin Center for Government & Public Integrity, a major policy research organization, reported that “Bass Pro and its closest competitor, Cabela’s, received or were promised more than $2.2 billion from taxpayers over the prior 15 years.”
Of course, Bridgeport isn’t the only small city to fall for Brass Pro’s pitch that they can anchor a major revitalization effort. Just a few years ago it was Buffalo, with its population of 261,310 residents (nearly twice the size of Bridgeport), that was promising Bass Pro big money in return for the company opening up a store that would serve as the hook for the Erie Canal Harbor Development Corporation (ECHDC) plan to revitalize Buffalo’s waterfront. In that case, Bass Pro wanted $35 million in public subsidies.
At the time, the New York based Public Accountability Initiative (PAI) conducted a major study of the impact Bass Pro would have on Buffalo and the region.
The Key findings of the PAI study included;
- Bass Pro often fails to deliver on its promise to be an economic development anchor and major tourist destination. Its stores attract shoppers but often do not produce sought-after economic benefits associated with major tourist destinations.
- A Mesa, AZ development anchored by a Bass Pro has been described as a “ghost town” and “dead” and spurred the state to pass a ban on retail subsidies.
- A taxpayer-subsidized Harrisburg, PA Bass Pro is struggling to attract tenants to the mall it anchors, leading to lawsuits, stalled renovations, and increasing stigma. Though the Bass Pro was expected to hire 300-400 employees according to initial projections, it had hired only 101 employees three years after opening.
- A Bass Pro-anchored mall in Cincinnati, OH, is only 35% leased and has been described as “positively post-apocalyptic” and “pretty much on life support” by visitors.
- The Bakersfield, CA Bass Pro site – still in development – is home to a waterless ditch that was intended to serve as the store’s canal. The site has sat vacant for ten years.
- Bass Pro has gone on a building spree over the past ten years that significantly undermines its claims that each new store is a major tourist destination.
For more on the study in Buffalo check the following news clip: Study says Bass Pro won’t spur growth
Meanwhile, Buffalo never got their store…
A few months ago, Bass Pro founder Johnny Morris announced that Bass Pro would be opening up on the Canadian side of the border saying, “It’s an incredible opportunity for Bass Pro Shops to place our third Canadian store in this beautiful part of Southern Ontario.”
Thanks to Governor Malloy, here in Connecticut, the claim that Bass Pro is an “incredible opportunity” is getting this extremely successful private company $45 million of our money.
Bridgeport, Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, First Five, Kenneth Moales, Malloy, Mayor Bill Finch, TicketNetwork Bridgeport, Community Bank, Donald Vaccaro, Economic Development, First Five, Kenneth Moales Jr., Malloy, TicketNetwork
In an article entitled, “State Has First Bank Failure In A Decade, the Hartford Courant reported last night that, “The Community’s Bank, with its headquarters and one branch in Bridgeport, came under the receivership of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. late Friday afternoon amid mounting losses from commercial real estate loans.”
“Shocked and saddened” is what Bridgeport Mayor Bill Finch said in a statement, adding “…It is not clear how the state could allow this to happen.”
Not clear how the state could allow this to happen?
What Mayor Finch failed to reveal and the Hartford Courant didn’t report is that The Community Bank is one of the mortgage holders that Finch campaign treasurer and Bridgeport Board of Education Chairman, Kenneth Moales Jr, has failed to repay.
Since April of this year, Wait, What? readers have been learning about the massive financial problems facing Moales his church.
See: Is Bridgeport Board of Education Chairman Kenneth Moales, Jr.’s financial empire collapsing? (April 30), Wait, What? Bridgeport Board of Education scheduled to approve $1 million for Moales Daycare facilities despite foreclosure threat (May 13), Moales Empire Collapsing, Moales’ state funded childcare sites being foreclosed on (June 20), Update: Moales Empire Collapsing, foreclosure to take his state funded childcare sites, churches and apparently his residence. (June 21) News Update: More on financial problems facing Bridgeport Board of Ed. Chair Kenneth Moales, Jr. and his church (June 26).
As reported in those articles, in addition to the $8 million plus in principal and interest owed to Foundation Capital Resources, Inc., Moales and his church owe hundreds of thousands more to various contractors, the City of Bridgeport, the state of Connecticut and Community Bank of Bridgeport.
The Community Bank of Bridgeport loaned Moales and his family $175,000. As collateral for that loan, Moales used his mother‘s residence, which is owned by Moales’ church, as well as the full faith and credit of the church.
Despite benefiting from a $1 million dollar day-care contract his family “won” from the Malloy administration and raking in hundreds of thousands of dollars from his parishioners, Moales failed has consistently failed to make his mortgage payments. One of the entities Moales has refused to pay is The Community Bank in Bridgeport.
Although Moales hasn’t made his legally required payments, he has had the funds to drive fancy cars, wear expensive suits, go on long vacations and send his children to the costly Fairfield Day School, all while supporting Mayor Bill Finch, faux superintendent Paul Vallas and their combined efforts to privatize and run the Bridgeport School System into the ground.
According to the Hartford Courant,
“Chartered in 2001, The Community’s Bank was the state’s only minority-owned lender, and its finances had come under increased scrutiny from regulators since 2010.The traditional focus of minority-owned banks on urban, rather than suburban, areas, provided a major obstacle to building the bank, said state Banking Commissioner Howard F. Pitkin, who issued Friday’s order.’They found it difficult to grow,’ Pitkin said. “They never reached the point where they were making money.”
While Moales’ connection to the demise of Bridgeport’s Community Bank is noteworthy, the Hartford Courant story revealed an equally unsettling development.
The Courant is reporting that, “Late last month, an investor group filed an application with the state Department of Banking for approval to invest in the bank and become a minority shareholder. The group was led by TicketNetwork Chief Executive Donald Vaccaro. A spokeswoman for Vaccaro said late Friday that the effort was supported by U.S. Reps. Jim Himes and John Larson.”
“The cash infusion that I would have provided [would have] meant more loans for inner city development, fewer blighted properties, and more jobs for inner city folks,” Vaccaro said in a statement. “Instead of a rescue by me, closing the bank will cost the state and the federal government millions of dollars and cause a loss of many jobs in the city of Bridgeport.”
The Courant went on to report that “a banking department spokesman, declined to comment late Friday because the application is pending.”
But as Wait, What? readers may recall, TicketNetwork and Vaccaro have been in the news before. TicketNetwork was chosen by Governor Malloy to be his 2nd “First Five” corporate welfare recipient.
See: Shhh… over here… I got some tickets – “cheap”, State Gives Company Millions to Create Jobs – Claims it didn’t know about employee lawsuit…, Oh those crazy CEO’s (aka Our Tax Dollars at Work), First Five Company #2 – TicketNetwork – Takes the Fall, They’re BACK! TicketNetwork moves to “corner” the world market by controlling domain names ending with “.tickets”
Malloy choose TicketNetwork, the “online ticket exchange company” (whatever you do, don’t call them ticket scalpers), despite the fact that Vaccaro and TicketNetwork had a pending lawsuit against the president of the Bushnell.
At the time Malloy announced the multi-million dollar deal with TicketNetwork, Vaccaro and his company had a lawsuit pending against the Bushnell’s David Fay for slander because Fay had spoken at a Connecticut legislative hearing calling for stronger laws to protect consumers and artistic venue such as the Bushnell.
TicketNetwork went to court seeking damages and demanding a retraction because the Bushnell’s representative said that TicketNetwork was “a company that puts tickets to popular events on ‘hold’ and then attempts to sell those tickets to third parties at inflated prices.”
According to the CEO of TicketNetwork, “Mr. Fay’s slanderous comments were made in order to influence Connecticut legislation. That is reprehensible and subverts the whole legislative process.”
When Governor Malloy was asked about the whole controversy surrounding ticket re-sellers and whether the state’s taxpayers should be supporting such an industry, Malloy said “that is all part of the growing pains of this new emerging market.” Malloy went on to say “”There will be winners and losers in any emerging industry” and that the solution is to set up appropriate rules and then, “quite frankly, get out of the way.”
At the time, Malloy’s corporate give-a-way plan to Vaccarro’s company also overlooked a major sexual harassment lawsuit that was pending against Vaccaro and TicketNetwork.
However, despite spending more than $127,000 on lobbying fees, when Vaccaro later verbally abused a bouncer at a Hartford gathering and uttered a string of racial slurs, TicketNetwork was convinced to withdraw his “First Five” application.
The fact that Vaccaro now shows up with an application to invest in Bridgeport’s Community Bank while claiming his application has the support of Congressmen John Larson and Jim Himes is certainly worthy of some more investigation.
As is, of course, the notion that Bridgeport’s Mayor, Bill Finch, is “shocked” and says “It is not clear how the state could allow this to happen,” when the official record reflects the fact that it was at it was Kenneth Moales whose actions helped tank this local community bank.
Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Economy, Malloy, Unemployment Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Economy, Malloy, Unemployment
As the blind man led the deaf man toward to edge of the precipice he was heard to utter….”things are looking up, we are almost there…”
Those words and that image could certainly be used to describe Governor Malloy’s approach to the Connecticut economy and his so-called economic development strategy of giving away hundreds of millions in taxpayer funds to successful multi-million dollar corporations.
“You can’t name a recent governor who’s had net job growth…I’m the one — no others.”
That is what Governor Malloy told listeners during a recent appearance on the Connecticut Public Radios show “Where We Live.”
But of course, the Governor’s statement wasn’t true.
And when informed of that, Malloy’s PR operation spun into high gear releasing a statement “clarifying” what the Governor meant when he uttered his inaccurate assessment of the truth. Malloy’s spokesman said;
“The Governor was referring to a fact that everyone in this state knows — that our economy had been stagnant for decades. We failed to invest in the industries that were poised to grow, and instead careened from one project to the next without any real cogent strategy. That can no longer be said about Connecticut’s economic development strategy.”
The Governor’s political two-stepping is the manifestation of the Malloy administration’s failed economic development strategies and his attempt to convince voters that the real world isn’t actually real.
The single greatest indication of the Governor’s utter detachment from the real world can be found in his response to the news that although the number of jobs in Connecticut increased in the month of July, Connecticut’s unemployment rate actually rose from 8 percent to 8.1 percent.
To that Malloy explained, “People are sensing that it’s easier to get a job.”
“It’s easier to get a job…” ?
Now that was certainly a Wait, What? moment!
As Malloy spends his time trying to count the number of angels that can fit on the top of a pin, tens of thousands of Connecticut residents feel the crushing pressure of Connecticut failing economic development strategy.
An August 2013 report from Connecticut Voices for Children, the non-partisan research group paints a grim picture of the state of the state when it comes to the Connecticut economy and especially “The State of Working Connecticut 2013: Young People in the Workforce.”
Governor Malloy and his administration would do well to study the report in detail.
CT Voices reports;
- Youth unemployment has dramatically increased in Connecticut over the last decade and is more than twice the rate for older workers.
- The unemployment rate for Connecticut’s young workers (age 16 to 24) is at about 17.1 percent, which is more than double the rate for 25 to 54 year olds (7.4 percent) and almost triple the rate for workers 55 and older (6.4 percent).
- Connecticut’s youth unemployment rate is higher than the United States average (16.2 percent).
Fewer people are looking for work because there is no work to be found;
- A smaller share of the working age population is working or looking for work. (The labor force participation rate is the share of the working age population that is working or looking for work.)
- The rate for all Connecticut workers fell from 68.8 percent in 2007 to 66.2 percent in 2012. The largest decline in participation is among the state’s youngest workers: the rate among 16 to 24 year olds in Connecticut declined over this period from 62.0 percent to 54.5 percent.
Long-term unemployment has reached crisis and historic levels:
- Long-term unemployment — the share of the unemployed who have been out of work for more than 26 weeks — was second highest in Connecticut among all states. Among Connecticut’s unemployed youth, one-third (33.6 percent) have been out of work for more than 26 weeks, above the national rate of 27.7 percent.
- And long-term unemployment is hurting older workers even more. In 2012, long-term unemployment in Connecticut for those age 55 and older, at 61.5 percent, was the highest rate for that age group among all 50 states.
Connecticut’s minority workers are disproportionately hurt by Connecticut’s economy.
- Connecticut’s Black and Hispanic workers face high unemployment and low wages. In 2012, Black unemployment (13.4 percent) and Hispanic unemployment (15.7 percent) were about double the White unemployment rate (7.0 percent).
- On average, Hispanics earned 55 cents and Blacks earned 72 cents for every dollar earned by Whites.
And Malloy’s corporate welfare program of giving out hundreds of millions to successful corporations will not create the breadth of jobs Connecticut needs.
As the CT Voices report explains, “While Connecticut has added jobs in the recent past; these jobs are among the state’s lowest-paid sectors. Connecticut added 15,655 jobs between 2011 and 2012. However, the majority of these jobs (10,050) were added in the lower-wage job sectors.”
Connecticut’s economic problems go much, much deeper than a governor who can’t seem to tell the truth about the state of the state’s economy.
Just ask the deaf man who is being led toward the cliff by the man who is blind.
You can find all this data and the rest of the CT Voices report at: http://www.ctvoices.org/sites/default/files/econ13sowctes.pdf and http://www.ctvoices.org/sites/default/files/econ13sowctfull.pdf
Bridgeport, Economic Development, Malloy, Paul Vallas, Stefan Pryor, Steven Adamowski Bridgeport, Economic Development, Malloy, Paul Vallas, Stefan Pryor, Steven Adamowksi
Updated with additional background on the contract between Paul Vallas and Teach for America
Last Monday night, Paul Vallas, Bridgeport’s faux superintendent of schools revealed that he had hired another 31 Teach for America recruits to staff Bridgeport’s schools this year. Few, if any of the recruits come from Connecticut and none went to a Connecticut college or university to become a teacher.
The TFA recruits come courtesy of a March 2013 deal between Vallas and Nate Snow, the Executive Director for the Connecticut Chapter of Teach for America. Snow is also the President of Excel Bridgeport, Inc. the corporate funded lobbying and advocacy group that has been Vallas’ strongest supporter, turning out crowds for public hearings and rallies in support of the embattled Bridgeport education reformer. Snow and Excel Bridgeport also played a vital role in support of Mayor Bill Finch’s failed charter revision effort that would have done away with an elected board of education and replaced it with one appointed by Finch.
Not only are TFA recruits paid at regular teacher salary levels, but in return for supplying the Teach for America recruits, Vallas committed the City of Bridgeport to pay TFA a “fee” of “$3,000 per year for the first two years a teacher is employed. According to the contract, the annual fee goes up next year to $3,105 a year and then to $3,214 the year after that.
In total, the Vallas/TFA contract calls for the City to hire 125 TFA teachers. That number would provide Nate Snow’s organization with a finder’s fee in excess of $750,000.
Meanwhile in Windham, Malloy’s Special Master, Steven Adamowski, has packed the Windham schools with more and more of these mostly out-of-state Teach for America students.
As a result of Adamowski’s actions, about one in five Windham teachers had just a few weeks of training rather than having gone through one of Connecticut’s university-based teacher training programs.
The approach that is being taken by school administrators like Vallas and Adamowski is leaving hundreds of new Connecticut trained teachers twisting slowly in the wind.
It was only last May that literally hundreds of Connecticut residents earned their teaching certificates, after four or five years-worth of work, at UConn, Connecticut State University or one of Connecticut’s Independent colleges or universities.
At UConn, for example, students have two different options when it comes to teacher preparation programs including the “highly competitive five-year comprehensive teacher preparation program that integrates coursework and school-based clinic experiences facilitated by university and K-12 faculty in the preparation of pre-service teachers.”
As UConn proudly reports, “Over the past few years, U.S. News & World Report has ranked the IB/M program among the top 25 teacher preparation programs in Elementary Education, Secondary Education, and Special Education. We are nationally accredited by the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education as well as the Connecticut State Board of Education. Further, certification through the IB/M program is recognized by forty states through the National Association of State Directors of Teacher Education & Certification Interstate Contract.”
But did Paul Vallas or Steven Adamowski hire these students or the others who came out of Central, Southern, Eastern, Western or one of the other colleges in the state?
The answer would be a big NO!
In fact, the teaching positions that went to the out-of-state Teach for America recruits weren’t even posted as vacancies, meaning Connecticut residents never even had a chance to compete for the spots.
Earlier this month, Governor Malloy told the media that the economy was improving and that he was the only Connecticut governor to have created jobs over the past two decades.
Of course his claim wasn’t true…but even worse, he tried to skip over the fact that according to Connecticut’s Department of Labor, “Connecticut’s unemployment rate was estimated at 8.1% for July 2013.” That means the percentage of unemployed actually increased over the summer.
There is nothing fundamentally wrong with giving a few Teach for America recruits the opportunity to get experience by teaching in our public schools but administrators like Vallas and Adamowski have been consistently blocking opportunities for our own Connecticut children… Children who went to college in Connecticut and developed the expertise and knowledge they needed to teach in our public schools.
Imagine, we have Connecticut students, and their families, who were forced to borrow tens of thousands of dollars to go to college. They took the right courses, they got the right grades, they completed their teacher preparation programs and they earned their teaching certification. But when they graduated they discovered that they couldn’t even apply for a significant number of jobs in Connecticut’s public schools because someone had cut a deal to give dozens of those jobs away to out-of-state kids who didn’t even need to take education courses.
Put aside all the issues associated with whether TFA recruits have sufficient training before being sent into the classroom.
The fact is that Connecticut’s economy remains derailed and instead of using every opportunity to create good jobs for Connecticut residents, Governor Malloy, Education Commissioner Stefan Pryor, Paul Vallas and Steven Adamowski are setting up systems that prevent our children from even applying for these good paying jobs.
And as if all of this wasn’t insulting enough to the hard working families of Connecticut, TFA recruits generally qualify for the various federal loan forbearance programs meaning that while getting full teacher salaries their student loans are being paid for by the United States Government.
So when all is said and done, instead of creating jobs for Connecticut residents, the TFA program blocks Connecticut residents from getting jobs, gives jobs to people who have not gone through Connecticut teacher preparation programs, diverts hundreds of thousands of dollars in Connecticut taxpayer funds to Teach for America in the form of finder’s fees and leaves our students with more debt…all while out-of-state students get their student loans paid for by the government for taking away jobs that should be going Connecticut residents who have worked so hard to become teachers.
It is a sad excuse for leadership in these troubled economic times.
Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Freedom of Information, Malloy Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Freedom of Information, Malloy
In the never-ending saga know as, “laws are for normal people” or “those laws are just technicalities” comes news that, “A state economic development agency that approved nearly $37 million in total aid to businesses in 2011 and 2012 failed to give public notice of its meetings during that time as required by law, the state auditors disclosed Wednesday.”
In an article entitled, Auditors: State agency doled out $37M while violating public notice law, the CT Mirror’s Keith Phaneuf writes, “The quasi-public Connecticut Development Authority also did not submit an annual schedule of its meetings with the Secretary of the State’s Office – another violation of Connecticut’s right-to-know laws.”
According to the news coverage;
“During the two-year audit period, the CDA approved a wide range of business assistance including:
$15.2 million in loans and $750,000 in loan guarantees for manufacturing projects that add jobs, enhance exports and support new uses for defense technology;
$8 million to insure loans to help companies acquire industrial land, buildings, machinery and equipment;
$5.6 million in loans to businesses to add machinery and equipment;
$1 million in guarantees for business loans deemed riskier than conventional business financing.”
As to that annoying debate about laws, Governor Malloy’s spokesperson was quick to add;
“It’s the auditors job to point out oversights such as this, and we’re glad they have…Every effort must be made to comply with these important rules, especially when they are designed to increase transparency. We’re glad to hear CDA agrees as well, and that they are committed to addressing the problem.”
So at least in this case, Malloy’s team was nice enough to clarify that these particular laws are only rules, but that the Governor’s Office is glad to hear that his state agency is committed to “addressing the problem” and following the rules in the future.
For more background on this story, check out the CT Mirror at: http://www.ctmirror.org/story/2013/07/31/auditors-state-agency-doled-out-37m-while-violating-public-notice-law
BassPro, Bridgeport, Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy, Mayor Bill Finch Bridgeport, Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy, Mayor Bill Finch
According to the Connecticut Post’s Brian Lockhart, “The state will spend at least $22 million to build Bass Pro Shops a mega-store on the [Bridgeport] city’s waterfront.”
As Wait, What? readers will recall from previous blog posts, Bass Pro, a $2.6 billion privately owned company, specializes in getting taxpayers to fund significant amounts of their development costs.
Last summer, the Franklin Center for Government & Public Integrity, reported that “Bass Pro and its closest competitor, Sidney, Nebraska-based Cabela’s, received or were promised more than $2.2 billion from taxpayers over the prior 15 years.”
It was just a year ago that Governor Malloy and Bill Finch had a spare-no-expense media announcement to share the news that “Missouri-based Bass Pro had agreed to be the anchor company at Steel Point, the empty land along alongside Bridgeport Harbor.
According to Lockhart’s story, “The company was lured to Connecticut with a package of unspecified financial incentives that were still being negotiated. Usually such details are available at the time of an announcement.”
Now, a year later, Connecticut Innovations, Inc. the Connecticut economic development agency’s controlled by the Governor has voted to borrow $22 million to help pay for Bass Pro’s new store.
Interestingly the State of Connecticut’s Department of Economic and Community Development explained that the $22 million will not be the only subsidy provided to Bass Pro.
The Malloy administration’s refusal to allow transparency in its economic development program has been a constant point of contention.
The Connecticut Post did determine that the state will be using a system called tax incremental financing to come up with the $22 million for Bass Pro. The state explained, “They are basically `lock boxing’ a portion of that future sales tax that they know is a net increase from sales tax currently generated in the state, and using that to pay off up front bonds.”
So, in essence, the state is borrowing money and giving up future sales tax revenue to pay it back, with interest.
The Connecticut Post also reported on the employment law problems Bass Pro has been facing. As reported, “In March, a U.S. District Court judge in Houston allowed the EEOC lawsuit, alleging the company turned away black and Hispanic applicants at stores nationwide, to move ahead… “
In addition to the $22 million, Mayor Finch has committed local taxpayer funds and money and federal grants to upgrade the infrastructure at Steel Point.
At this point, Connecticut’s total public subsidy to Bass Pro remains unknown.
Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy Corporate Welfare, Economic Development, Malloy
On June 19, 2012 Governor Malloy announced that Alexion Pharmaceuticals would become the fourth company to collect taxpayer subsidies (aka Corporate Welfare) under his “First Five” economic development initiative.
With much fanfare, Malloy announced that $51 million in taxpayer funds were being given to Alexion Pharmaceuticals to help persuade the $20 billion dollar company to move from Cheshire back to New Haven where the company had begun in 1992. In return for the money, the company would also promise to create 200-300 jobs.
Thirteen months later, on July 13, 2013, Switzerland’s Roche Holding AG, the world’s largest cancer pharmaceutical company, announced that is rounding up the funds to takeover Alexion Pharmaceuticals.
In 1992, Alexion Pharmaceuticals was opened by Yale faculty member Dr. Leonard Bell in New Haven’s Science Park. Eight years later it moved to Cheshire. Bell remains the company’s CEO.
So, with the development of Governor Malloy’s “First Five” program, Alexion was one of the companies to put their hand out. As noted, Last year, in return for promising to move back to New Haven and create 200-300 new jobs, Governor Malloy gave the company a corporate welfare package worth $51 million.
According to the Connecticut Department of Economic and Community Development, the package included, “A 10-year loan of $20 million at a rate of 1% with principal and interest deferred for five years. Loan forgiveness of $16 to $20 million will be based on the creation of 200-300 full-time jobs; a $6 million grant for laboratory construction and equipment and Urban and Industrial Sites Reinvestment Tax Credits of up to $25 million.”
At a press conference held by Governor Malloy and Mayor DeStefano, Alexion’s CEO explained, “Our new headquarters in New Haven will support the rapid growth of our company as we expand our global mission to transform the lives of patients with severe and life-threatening ultra-rare disorders.”
As part of the deal, Winstanley Enterprises, of West Hartford and Massachusetts is scheduled to build a “$100 million, state-of-the-art, laboratory and office building” at New Haven’s “Downtown Crossing.”
David Winstanley and his two sons, Adam and Carter have been in the commercial real-estate business for many years focusing on the acquisition and development of buildings within the Yale Science Park and facilities for ESPN, among others. In the last New Haven mayoral election, the Winstanley family of Concord, Massachusetts gave DeStefano at least $10,000 and the family and its associates have donated over $26,000 to state-level politicians in Connecticut over the last few election cycles.
At the time of the Malloy/Alexion press conference, the Republican leaders of the Connecticut General Assembly, Senator McKinney and Representative Cafero, complained that a public hearing should have been held on the corporate aid package before the funds were turned over to the private corporation.
Senator McKinney was quoted as saying, “Ultimately, I hope this is a good investment for the state of Connecticut, but the public and the legislature have a right to know more about the deal.”
But remaining true to their arrogant approach to criticism or the call for greater transparency, Governor Malloy’s spokesman, Andrew Doba, blasted the legislators sayings, “With all due respect to the minority leaders, sometimes you get the feeling that they look for clouds on a sunny day…”
At the time, Doba said the state’s interests were protected claiming, “We have extensive safeguards in place to protect taxpayers, including collateral requirements, a 10-year residency requirement, job creation and retention targets and capital investment requirements.” he said.
But one year later, major storm clouds have, indeed, appeared on the horizon.
On Saturday, Bloomberg News broke that Roche Holdings, a company based in Basel, Switzerland is trying to acquire Alexion.
Bloomberg News reported that Roche Holdings recently dropped its hostile takeover effort of Illumine Inc., a $6.7 billion dollar pharmaceutical company and is instead turning its attention on purchasing Alexion.
According to Bloomberg News, “A takeover of Alexion would be Roche’s largest since the company bought the portion of Genentech Inc. it didn’t already own for $46.8 billion four years ago, the biggest biotechnology deal on record, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.”
Bloomberg News went on to report that “a spokesman for Roche, declined to comment. Irving Adler, a spokesman for Alexion, said the company doesn’t comment on rumors.”
According to the news reports, “Alexion climbed 13 percent to $114.26 yesterday in New York, the biggest single-day gain since October 2008. Roche’s American depositary receipts fell less than 1 percent to $64… [And]…Alexion’s shares climbed as much as 24 percent in intraday trading yesterday, matching a potential premium Roche could be expected to offer.”
Interestingly, none of the stories about the potential Roche/Alexion deal made any mention of the Connecticut taxpayer’s $51 million dollar gift to Alexion or the fact Alexion has “committed” to moving from Cheshire to New Haven and creating 200-300 jobs.
For additional background information check out: