An update on Students for Education Reform, Inc.
SFER is a model of how the Pro-Charter School and Corporate Education Reform Industry works to control the narrative surrounding public education while seeking to “win the hearts and minds of federal, state and local policymakers.
Dedicated to promoting the privatization of public education, more taxpayer funds for privately owned, but publicly funded charter schools, the Common Core, the Common Core testing scheme and a host of anti-teacher initiatives, Students for Education Reform, Inc. (SFER) was created in late 2009, according to their narrative, by a couple of undergraduate students at Princeton University.
Claiming to have over 100 chapters across the country, the “student run” advocacy group has, as of late last summer, collected more than $7.3 million since its inception to fund their “education reform” activities.
According to the organization’s most recent Internal Revenue Service (IRS) 990 reports (2014), in addition to the $5.7 million that has flowed into SFER’s coffers as of September 1, 2014, an additional $1.6 million has been collected by a closely-related company called the SFER Action Network Inc. which appears to serve as the political arm of SFER and formed in 2013.
Although Students for Education Reform is “run” by students, the self-described “grassroots” group is governed by a Board of Directors that is made up of some of the biggest corporate executives and players associated with the Corporate Education Reform Industry.
SFER’s website reports that the present Students for Education Reform Board of Directors includes;
April Chou (Chair) – The Chief Growth Officer at the KIPP Bay Area Charter School chain.
Adam Cioth (Treasurer) – The founder of Rolling Hills Capital hedge fund and a major funder of the public school privatization movement.
Christy Chin – The Managing Director of the Draper Richards Kaplan Foundation, the philanthropy arm of the venture capital firm, Draper Richards. The Foundation is one of SFER’s funders.
Stuart Cobert – The Deputy General Counsel at the Unilever Corporation.
Justin Cohen – The President of Mass Insight, a major corporate education reform consulting company.
Shavar Jeffries – Recently appointed President of Democrats for Education Reform (DFER), Jeffries was recently the unsuccessful “education reform” candidate for Mayor of Newark, New Jersey.
Nancy Poon Lue – A Partner in the Silicon Valley Social Venture Fund
And Chris Stewart, Director of Outreach and External Affairs for the Gates Foundation funded Pro-Corporate Education Reform Blog called Education Post.
Until recently the SFER Board also included acclaimed education reform financier Jonathan Sackler (Whose activities include funding the Achievement First Inc. charter school chain, forming ConnCAN and 50CAN and serving on the Board of The New Schools Venture Fund) and Rebecca Ledley (A member of the UP Academy Charter School Company and spouse of Charles Ledley, who serves on the Board of Directors of Education Reform Now (ERN) and its affiliate, Democrats for Education Reform (DFER.)
Earlier SFER Board members included Brian Olson, who presently serves as Chairman of ConnCAN and Matthew Kramer, President of Teach for America. Kramer also served with Sackler on the 50CAN Board of Directors.
The Board of Directors for SFER’s political arm, SFER Action Network Inc. is chaired by SFER’s Board Treasurer, Adam Cioth. SFER Action Network’s Board also includes SFER Board members Chris Stewart a Rebecca Ledley.
Other members of the SFER Action Network Inc. Board include Meg Ansara and John Petry.
Ansara is a Washington D.C. consultant who worked with the education reform group Stand for Children for many years.
Petry is infamous for his relationship with Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy charter school chain and his role in getting her company off the ground and supporting it through the years. Perty is also the co-founder of Democrats for Education Reform (DFER.) and previously served as Chairman of Education Reform Now. (ERN)
So where is SFER getting its money?
Although SFER claims to have sprung up on its own, its formation can be traced directly to Education Reform Now (ERN) which served as SFER’s initial fiduciary and has provided SFER with at least $1.6 million since its inception.
Education Reform Now (ERN) is actually a conglomerate of three different corporate entities.
As Nation Magazine and others have reported, Education Reform Now (ERN), Education Reform Now Advocacy, Inc. and Democrats For Education Reform (DFER) are all part of the same “Education Reform” advocacy apparatus.
DFER, the group’s Political Action Committee has spent millions to undermine public education and support pro-corporate education reform candidates and initiatives.
For example, DFER spent about $1 million on television attack ads against the Chicago Teachers Union during that union’s successful strike.
DFER also joined with the Koch brothers, ALEC and a series of anti-union, right-wing groups to fund efforts to limit the ability of organized labor to use payroll deductions for political activities.
Like many other corporate education reform groups, SFER has been especially aggressive in working to keep people from identifying where the front group gets its funds.
An earlier version of SFER’s website reported that the entity’s “funding partners” included 50CAN, ConnCAN, Teach for America, Stand for Children, Kickboard and the Breakthrough Collaborative.”
However that information has disappeared from SFER’s present website.
What is known is that the Walton Foundation (Wal-Mart Family) gave SFER $250,000 in 2012, $650,000 in 2013 and $300,000 in 2014.
During the same time period, the Walton Foundation also gave 50Can $8.5 million and another $6 million to Education Reform Now. Some of those funds may have made their way to Students for Education Reform (SFER.)
SFER may also have collected Gates Foundation funds, Gates provided 50CAN with more than $2.4 million between 2012 and 2014.
Another donor of record to SFER is The New Schools Venture Fund which is not surprising since Jonathan Sackler served on both organizations’ boards and Adam Cioth and Brian Olsen are members of the New Schools Venture Fund Leadership Council.
A description of how SFER works can be found in a 2014 Minnesota Post article entitled, “A ‘crazy’ amount of money is being spent on Minneapolis school-board races; Reporting on massive amount of outside money was being spent on the race for the Minneapolis school board, the Minnesota paper reported;
The Student for Education Reform (SFER) Action Network Fund reported receipts of $26,000, $23,500 of which was a single donation from Adam Cioth and the remainder from Ben Whitney.
An investment banker, Cioth sits on SFER’s board. He is active both in the charter and traditional public school sectors, as well as the nonprofit startup New Schools Venture Fund. Ben Whitney headed up George Bush’s 2004 Minnesota campaign and chairs the board of the education advocacy group MinnCAN.
According to the disclosures, the SFER effort donated $16,000 worth of canvassing to MinnCAN’s political committee, the 50CAN Action Fund. It also paid for $4,350 worth of 50CAN literature and spent $5,000 for voter files and organizing software.
In addition to SFER’s contributions, the 50CAN Action Fund reported receiving $4,305 in cash from the student group and $10,000 from Arthur Rock, a San Francisco venture capitalist who sits on the board of Teach for America.
The 50CAN Action Fund took in a total of $35,000 and spent some $13,000 on campaign materials.
Local Republican financier Benson Whitney, chair of the board of the education reform organization MinnCAN (the state-level branch of 50CAN) and a supporter of Samuels, gave $2,500 of the $26,000, while California charter school investor and SFER board member Adam Cioth provided the other $23,500 in funds.
Another leading example of how SFER works can be found via the National Council on Teacher Quality (NCTQ), the corporate funded group seeking to “transform” the teaching profession by undermining teachers, teacher education programs and attacking teacher unions.
NCTQ’s dedicates a page on their website to proudly proclaim their allies and partners include…. Students For Education Reform (SFER) along with a list of other education reform groups including;
Democrats for Education Reform
DFER New Jersey
DFER New York
DFER Rhode Island
Education Reform Now
Educators 4 Excellence
MarylandCAN: Maryland Campaign for Achievement Now
Mass Insight Education & Research Institute
MinnCAN: Minnesota Campaign for Achievement Now
NYCAN: New York Campaign for Achievement Now
PennCAN: Pennsylvania Campaign for Achievement Now
RI-CAN: Rhode Island Campaign for Achievement Now
When Diane Ravitch was asked about SFER in an interview she responded;
“I find it bizarre that students at any level would demand more standardized tests, and would demand that teachers be held accountable based on student test scores…Why would students promote a method that testing experts say is inaccurate for measuring teacher quality and that promotes narrowing the curriculum and teaching to the test?” – Diane Ravitch
To read more about Students for Education Reform (SFER) check out the following links;
Astroturf Activism: Who is Behind Students for Education Reform? (The Nation)
$tudent$ for Education Reform (EduShyster)
How $tudent$ 4 Education Reform Jumped the Shark (EduShyster)
How to spot a fake ‘grassroots’ education reform group (Washington Post)
Students For Education Reform? Not the Change We Need (Good Magazine)
Rethinking “Youth-Led” – Students for Education Reform (Gen Y Not)